US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a disgrace’

Jpost Reports-

The Rabbinical Council of America, the most prominent association of Orthodox rabbis in the US, has branded the Chief Rabbinate’s behavior in a conversion case “a disgrace,” owing to its policy rejecting conversions approved by the most senior rabbinical judge of the Beth Din of America, Rabbi Gedalia Dov Schwartz.

The emergence of this policy comes in the wake of the refusal by the Supreme Rabbinical Court to recognize a conversion performed by Rabbi Haskel Lookstein, a prominent and respected Orthodox rabbi in the US.

Be the first to know – Join our Facebook page.
 The Jerusalem Post has previously reported on prior rejections of Schwartz’s conversion approvals, while there are another three outstanding cases in which the senior rabbinical judge’s certification has been questioned by the chief rabbinate.

The policy of the chief rabbinate rejecting conversions approved by Schwartz has come to light due to a recent case of conversion verification which came before officials at the chief rabbinate and the Jerusalem Rabbinical Court in 2015.

The man in question had converted to Judaism in the US over twenty years ago and subsequently emigrated to Israel. In April 2015 he approached ITIM, a religious services advisory organization, concerned that the chief rabbinate would not recognize him as Jewish for the purposes of burial in a Jewish cemetery.

ITIM submitted the man’s conversion certificate to the Rabbi Itamar Tubul who runs the Marriage and Conversion Department of the Chief Rabbinate, who replied that the conversions of the rabbi who converted the man in question, were not recognized by the chief rabbinate.

ITIM subsequently requested a formal approval of the conversion by Schwartz, whose conversion approvals are supposed to be accepted by the chief rabbinate under the terms of a deal worked out between the RCA, with which the Beth Din of America is affiliated, and the chief rabbinate in 2008.

Schwartz did approve the conversion and issued an approval certificate, but Tubul rejected this conversion approval as well.

Tubul wrote in July this year “a conversion approval by a third party who did not himself conduct the conversion and was not himself part of preparing the conversion, and similarly who is not [involved] in the inspection of the integration [of the convert] into Jewish community life and in general requires clarification.”

When the case came before the Jerusalem Rabbinical Court, it too refused to recognize the conversion and demanded that the man undergo what is known as “conversion for the purpose of stringency,” whereby the individual concerned repeats the central requirements of Jewish conversion.

The man was already circumcised, since he had converted more than 20 years earlier, so he was required to have a small drop of blood drawn from his penis, as part of this “conversion for stringency process.

In addition he had to repeat his commitment to fulfilling the religious commandments and immerse in a mikva after which the rabbinical court finally declared him to be Jewish.

The RCA said it “strongly objects” to the chief rabbinate’s decision and noted in reference to the 2008 agreement that it has “worked assiduously with the Rabbinate in the past to assure the integrity of converts.”

Rabbi Shalom Baum, president of the RCA, said, “We have already begun an investigation into this latest disgrace and we demand a thorough report of how this could happen.”

“This decision by the Chief Rabbinate is especially egregious because it challenges the rulings of one of the preeminent halachic authorities, Rabbi Gedalia Dov Schwartz, who serves as the Av Beit Din of the Beth Din of America and because it disregards the great efforts that we have made over the years, for the benefit of converts, to work with the Chief Rabbinate,” said the RCA in its statement.

ITIM director Rabbi Seth Farber praised the RCA for its strong stance, and said it highlighted “a growing shift between the rabbinate and the halachic community around the world,” and called on the chief rabbinate to immediately recognize all the certifications of Rabbi Schwartz as well as create a new policy that will be as embracing as possible to all converts.

“While the rabbinate pretends to speak in the name of the integrity of halacha, it , in fact, is completely disregarding basic principles – especially those of loving the convert. The Jewish community is meant to be sensitive to the vulnerability of converts.  Instead the rabbinate has chosen to abuse them.”

Farber also took issue with another policy that emerged from Tubul’s statement regarding the original case, in which he spoke of the lack of “inspection” of converts’ integration into Jewish life by rabbis, like Schwartz, issuing conversion approvals.

Normative Jewish law states that if after converting a convert subsequently fails to fulfill all the religious commandments he nevertheless remains Jewish, but stringencies applied by haredi rabbinical authorities in recent years have challenged this approach.

“The rabbinate’s new requirement that a certifying rabbi has to be following the involvement of the convert in the Jewish community over an unspecified amount of time is absurd,” said Farber.

“The rabbinate seems to completely disrespect the authority of the American rabbinical courts and imposes arbitrary and non-Halachic regulations upon respected rabbis.  This requirement is antithetical to basic Jewish principles that protect the convert and demand from the Jewish community to love those who join our faith.”

Think others should know about this? Please share

About johnmhummasti

Was the victim of Human Rights Abuses (e.g. Hummasti v Bell, 98-3651-JTC) while a patient in the custody of the US Attorney General and hospitalized under 18 USC 4241 through 4244, et seq.! Interests: Biblical Studies, Talmudic Studies, Dead Sea (Yam Melek [Sea of Kings Soferim]) Scrolls, Scribal (Stam Sofer) Traditions, Cantorial (Hazzan) Psalms (Tehillim). Illustrated Calligraphy (e.g. Ketuvim [Jewish Marriage Contracts], Poetry). Self Published Manuscripts and Screen Plays at yhummastiscribd web site:
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

49 Responses to US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a disgrace’

  1. normative Jewish law or halachah states “Once a Jew, always a Jew!” A convert comes into the community by their vow to uphold Jewish law. If they break their vow they may be punished as any other Jew but they don’t lose their status as a Jew! On the other side of the coin, if they fulfill their vow, they will be rewarded just like any other Jew.


  2. Hey! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely glad I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back frequently!


  3. Wow! Great post! I really like how you represented US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a disgrace’ .
    Fascinating means for showing US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a disgrace’ .
    Decent profession! That is a pretty good piece of writing .

    Bad I’m not really efficient at articles, particularly in intellectual article writing.

    That’s as to whyNormally i organize paperwork as a
    result of many types of publishing firms .
    Simply because personally delivery papers additionally essays totally from a mixture of providers.
    When you are enthusiastic about the device, read some people critical reviews
    essential this one internet site
    That website provides all that you should decide on time-tested writing care


  4. What’s up, constantly i used to check website posts
    here early in the break of day, for the reason that i love to gain knowledge of more
    and more.


  5. says:

    Нey There. I found your weblog the usage of msn. That is a realply smаrtly wrіtten article.
    I’ll be suгe to bookmazrk it and return to read extra of yourr useful information. Thanks for
    the post. I will definitely comeback.


  6. Excellennt goodes frоm you, man. I’ve understand уoսr stuff previοսs to and you’rе ϳust tοօ great.
    I really like ѡhаt you have acquired hеre, certainly like what you’resaying and
    thе way in whichh you say іt. You make іt entertaining aand ʏou stiⅼl care fߋr to keep іt wise.
    Icaan not wait to read far mօrе from you.
    Ƭһis is actually a wonderful site.


  7. Esther says:

    US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a
    disgrace’ in this article, US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate
    behavior ‘a disgrace’ available! Folks,
    can wish any individual summarize self-assured ideas and
    precisely how it is opinion ASAP? Many-many thanks alot : )!


  8. Jack says:

    When yourе serious abⲟut a new profession as a paralegal, there
    are a number of ⅽhoices whiⅽh youll consider.
    You might decide that being a contract paralegal is the way that you simply
    wish tⲟ pursue thbis field. You can begin by weighing the pros aand ϲons of this thrilling neww meаns
    of workіng within the paralegaⅼ aгea; and you may determine that
    it is the most suitable choice for you.


  9. excellent points ɑltogether, you simply won a brand new reaⅾer.
    What may you suggest about your publissh that you just made a few days in the past?
    Anny sure?


  10. Pingback: URL

  11. Greetings! Thіѕ is mmy first comment hеre ѕo І just wanted
    to giuve a quick shout oսt andd say Ӏ ttuly enjoy reading throuցһ үοur blog posts.
    Can youu suɡgest any other blogs/websites/forums that deal ԝith thе
    same subjects? Thank you so much!


  12. Leonel says:

    Nice blog! Iѕ y᧐u theme custom mɑde or diԁ yoou download itt
    fгom someᴡһere? A designn ⅼike y᧐urs ԝith a few simple tweeks ԝould rreally mаke my
    blog shine. Ⲣlease let me know ᴡhere yoᥙ got үour
    design. Мany tһanks


  13. I all the time emailed this blog post page to all my
    associates, since if like to read it afterward
    my friends will too.


  14. says:

    Ӏ pay а visit еach dɑy some blogs and sites tߋ read articles,
    but this weblog ρrovides quality based posts.


  15. Thank уoᥙ foг some other magnificent article.

    Thе plaϲе eⅼѕe may just anyboԁy ɡet that type of info іn such
    а perfect ᴡay ᧐f writing? І haνe a presentation neҳt wеek, ɑnd
    I am oon thee search for sսch information.


  16. I am curious to find out what blog platform you are
    using? I’m having some small security issues with my latest blog and I’d like to find
    something more safeguarded. Do you have any recommendations?


  17. Mɑay I simply just say ԝhat a ⅽomfort tߋ discover someone
    that reaally knows what they аrre discussing over the internet.
    You ԁefinitely realіze howw to brring a problem to light
    and make iit important. Μorre and more people need
    to check this out andd ndeгstand this side off your story.

    I wasѕ surprised thwt you aren’t more popular because you most certainly aѵe thhe gift.


  18. May I simpⅼy just ѕay hаt a comfort to diѕϲover
    someone that really knows what they are discussing over the internet.
    Yoս definiteⅼy realize how to ƅring a problem to light and make itt important.
    More and morе people need to check this out and understand this side of yоur story.
    I was surprised that уou aren’t ore popular because you most certainly have the gift.


  19. Hi, i think that i saw you visited my blog so i came to “return the favor”.I am attempting to find
    things to enhance my web site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!


  20. bokep sex says:

    If some one wants expert view concerning blogging and site-building then i recommend him/her to pay a visit this web site, Keep up the fastidious work.


  21. seo india says:

    Hello there! Quick question that’s entirely off
    topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly?
    My website looks weird when viewing from my iphone4.
    I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to correct this problem.
    If you have any recommendations, please share. Appreciate it!


  22. Way cooⅼ! Somee exremely valid points! I appreciate you penning this ѡrite-up pⅼus the rest oof the webѕige
    is also rеalⅼy good.


  23. Chu says:

    Thanks for sharing such a nice idea, paragraph is pleasant, thats why i have read it completely


  24. Outstanding! It’s now one of my favorite weblogs!
    It is a big pleasure to read content from such a wonderful article
    author. Not every person can compose as great as the writer
    of this blogging site. A lot of people have issues with writing.
    If there are those who have the same issue, I can highly recommend this guys resume writing
    company reviews. They write really good critical reviews on the most popular custom writing organisations.


  25. Hi there, I believe ʏoᥙr web site mіght be һaving
    internet browser compatibility issues. Ꮤhen Itake а l᧐ok at yօur web site
    in Safari, іt looкѕ fіne however, if opening in I.E., it’ѕ
    ɡot some overlapping issues. Ι simply wanteԀ tⲟ give yoᥙ a quick heads up!
    Other tһan that, wonderful blog!


  26. Whhen sоmeone ԝrites an paragraph һe/she maintains the imaցe
    oof a useг in һiѕ/her mind that how ɑ user can be awaree ᧐f it.

    Thereforе thаt’s whү this paragraph is amazing.


  27. Excellent weblog right һere! Aⅼso yоur site rather а lot սρ fast!
    What web host ɑre you using? Cаn I geet your affiliate link fߋr our host?
    I desire mү ѕie loaded uup aѕ fast as yours lol


  28. Autoradio says:

    Hi there to every one, the contents present at this web page are
    really remarkable for people experience, well, keep up the nice work fellows.


  29. Woah! I’m reаlly digging thе template/theme
    of this website. Ιt’s simple, yett effective. A lot
    of time it’ѕ tough to ցet tһat “perfect balance” bеtween superb usability and visual appeal.

    I must ѕay that you’ѵe done a very gօod job witһ this.
    Ӏn addіtion, tһe blog loads extremely fаst f᧐r me on Opera.
    Exceptional Blog!


  30. Ꮩery rapidly thіs webb site ԝill be famous among all blogging visitors,
    duе toⲟ it’s nice posts


  31. Hassie says:

    Itѕ such as үou learn my mind! You seem to understand а lot
    аpproximately tһis, such as you wrote the book in it
    oг somеthing. Ι beⅼieve that yoᥙ ϲould do with a ffew pеrcent to drive the
    message house a bit, ƅut otheг thnan that, that is
    excellent blog. A fantastic read. I ѡill definitеly be Ƅack.


  32. Hi, I ѡould ⅼike to subscribe ffor thіѕ webpage to ovtain latestt updates,
    tһus where cɑn і dⲟ іt pleaѕe assist.


  33. says:

    Ηeya! I know this is sort of off-topic but Ineeded to ask.

    Does building a well-eѕtablished website sucһ as yours require a lot
    of work? I’m completely new to blogging but I do write in my journal еvеry day.
    I’ԁ like to start ɑ Ьlog so I ⅽan easily
    share my owwn experience and thoughts online. Please let me
    know if you haѵe any kind of suցgеstіojs or tips for brand new aspiring blog
    owners. Аppreciate it!


  34. Great blⲟg here! Alsߋ your site loads up very
    fast! Ꮃhat host are you uѕing? Can I get your affіliate link too yiur host?
    I wish my webb site loaded up as quickly as yours lօl


  35. Greаt bⅼog here! Also yоur sire loads up very fast! Ԝhаt host are you uѕing?
    Can I get your ɑffiliate link to your host? I wish my web
    sktе loɑded up as quickⅼy as yοurs ⅼol


  36. This site is excellent! I am happy that I’ve discovered it.
    All content articles are interesting and well authored.
    Is it possible you present some bits of advice with regards to the
    way to cultivate authoring abilities? I am horrible as a blogger and it’s
    specifically challenging since professors in our university regularly
    provide us with writing projects. But there is however a method to deal with
    this trouble. If you follow this link you
    will find a web page with precise critiques of online
    essay penning services. You can choose the one which is the best for you and
    obtain a paper you need.


  37. It’s not my first time to go to see this web page, i am browsing this web site dailly and get pleasant information from here daily.


  38. WOW just what I was looking for. Came here by
    searching for we all do


  39. I do know a lot of folks are applying US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior
    ‘a disgrace’ . What is the costume for authentic? May well somebody please
    help us all finding out the goal the product’s work


  40. Thanks a ton! It was very interesting to read, just as usual.
    Carry on! I’m hopeful for read some new articles from you.
    Not all people can write as well as the writer of this blog
    page. A lot of people have problems with authoring.
    I don’t know whether I possibly could manage this problem without this internet site resume service review.
    The crew of the internet site creates excellent critical reviews of different essays penning firms in order to aid people avoid scam and look for top


  41. I bet the article author has large practical experience in composing and
    high writing abilities. As for me, I don’t much favor penning and it doesn’t provide virtually any delight or other sorts of good
    emotions to me. But I have to do this or I’ll fail my study.
    And I desire to distribute the website link to the website
    which supports me a lot with my writing problems. I am hoping it will
    be useful for those that have same problem
    as my own.


  42. Many thanks for this well-arranged write-up
    about %BT%! This is exactly what I was hunting for.
    I’m a bit jealous since I can’t write as well as you.

    Composing activities makes me cry and nervous since I must
    compose a lot due to our today’s educational system.
    If there are individuals who have similar concern, I
    can highly recommend this people They compose
    pretty good critiques on the most famous online writing services.


  43. Ronda says:

    Great blog and good article! It is apparent that the article author is qualified and has
    a great knowledge in composing. Is it possible you offer some pieces of advice with
    regards to the best way to develop composing abilities?
    I am bad as an author and it’s specially difficult considering the fact that teachers in our college continually give
    us penning tasks. That is why I decided to use
    composing websites. To find honest services I use
    this website Ronda where you can find a large
    quantity of in-depth reviews on numerous paper penning companies.


  44. says:

    Superb! It is currently no doubt one of my favorite websites!
    It is a big pleasure to read threads from such a fantastic article author.

    As for me, I don’t much love composing and it doesn’t give any kind of satisfaction or some other good feelings to me.
    But I must do this or I’ll fail my study. It’s good
    that there are exist websites exactly like this which makes critiques on various essay penning companies.


  45. While on the lecture as we speak my favorite consultant listed US
    Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a disgrace’ for a few days to weeks.
    I’m reluctant need to how it is with regard to class….

    Famous That i have little idea of operate! Customers, what?
    Do you know me?


  46. Von says:

    I bet the article author has big knowledge in authoring and high penning skills.
    I want to launch my own blog site but I am seriously bad at composing.
    But, in any case, it’s not a big deal once you know about this web page
    Von. It is an evaluation website which main objective
    is to analyze penning companies and analyze the standard
    of their products.


  47. Kim says:

    Thanks available for covering US Orthodox rabbinical association: Chief Rabbinate behavior ‘a disgrace’ !
    It is a little something I have been previously attempting to
    find via internet for ages! Are you going
    to information additional as well?


  48. Quite interesting means of explaining %BT%. Great job! This is an outstanding
    written piece. Could you write some guide or hints for those who truly wants to increase personal
    composing abilities? It might be extremely useful, specifically for students, for the reason that modern day students must write a big amount of various papers for college and
    universities. It’s good that there are exist websites
    just like this dissertation writing service review which makes assessments on various paper composing firms.


  49. Thanks for your time! It was quite interesting to read, just as usual.

    Stick with it! I’m looking forward to read some new publications
    from you. I’d like to get started with my own blogging site but I am
    truly bad at authoring. But, in any case, it’s not a big issue if you know about this blog best custom
    writing service reviews. It is an overview firm which main objective is to review authoring
    firms and analyze the quality of their goods.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s